Emily Post for the digital generation.

When politeness isn’t

The other day I posted a guide to eating lunch at your desk. I didn’t just come up with it out of nowhere. Oh no. I came up with it as I gently sauted garlic and anchovies in olive oil that evening, and remembered a guy I used to work with.

Peter sat at the desk across from me in the cubefarm. He wore a tie, and he was the only guy who did. He also objected to anyone eating their lunch at their desk. Not just food that was full of garlic and anchovies, but any hot food at all. He complained on my second day, when I reheated something innocuous in the vegie-tomato-pasta line and tried to eat it around 12:30.

Now, there are lots of times when it’s annoying to have people eating at their desk. Outside of normal mealtimes can be particularly distracting; I struggle with this one because I get all low-blood-sugary around 4pm and really want to eat something substantial. If there’s a lunchroom I’m set, but if there’s not then I’m torn between distracting my co-workers or sitting there headachey and braindead.

But Peter… Peter objected to perfectly ordinary lunches being eaten at perfectly ordinary times. He raised the issue politely, saying that he found it distracting and would I mind terribly not doing it. And, like an idiot, I complied. I spent the next little while avoiding eating lunch, because there was nowhere else in the building to eat. My other option required leaving the office, walking for 10 minutes, and paying for fairly expensive take-out food. Instead I munched on dried fruit and got headachey and absolutely hated the whole experience.

It wasn’t til Peter politely asked me something else that I realised what was going on. See, he very nicely mentioned that the second computer under my desk had a rather noisy fan, and would I mind turning it off? I said no, it was acting as a server and a number of people were using it, and it needed to be left on. The fan wasn’t all that noisy; I hadn’t noticed it and nobody else had commented, so I figured he could live with it.

A few days later, when I was working from home, he switched off that PC without notice, dumping me out and preventing me from working.

Peter wasn’t being polite. He was being a manipulative bastard. In a calm and friendly tone, he’d ask people to take extraordinary measures to ensure his comfort, and people would usually fall for it. He’d happily cost people time and money or prevent them from working to protect his delicate sensibilities.

I moved desks.

Don’t be fooled: just because someone sounds polite doesn’t mean they’re being polite. And don’t feel that you have to be a doormat to be polite in return.

Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

3 Comments so far

  1. Monica May 15th, 2007 8:32 pm

    Peter was being a jerk. You do not need to give in to unreasonable demands.

    That said, I’d like advice on handling a legitimate variation on his problem. I’ve got a coworker who apparently figured out how to eat by watching barnyard animals or something. You can hear the guy chewing pizza from 30 feet away, and crunchy stuff like chips is worse. He snacks at his desk extensively. It’s really revolting. Fortunately for me the problem has now been reduced to lunch meetings; after a recent office shuffle he no longer sits 20 feet from me. But I never figured out how to tell the guy that he’s pretty far outside the norm and it grosses me out; I feel like avoiding him is cheating, but that’s what I do. Any advice?

  2. Skud May 27th, 2007 5:45 pm

    Monica,

    Sorry this took me a while to respond to — the website didn’t notify me of this comment by email, for some reason.

    I’m going to promote your comment up into a post, and respond to it there within the next few days.

    K.

  3. [...] to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!Monica asks, in reponse to an earlier post about the guy who complained about people eating at their desks: I’ve got a coworker who apparently figured out how to eat by watching barnyard animals or [...]

Leave a reply